0

Which of the 4 Horsemen Pushes Your Buttons?

Therapists may exhibit the Four Horsemen when triggered during couples therapy. Learn how to recognize these patterns to improve clinical effectiveness.

Couples therapist getting triggered in session.

Sometimes even therapists display the Four Horsemen. Let me tell you about a therapeutic rupture I caused a while ago.

In a previous session Dan had made a commitment to his partner Shelley not to contact an ex. Shelley found out that he’d broken his commitment when she picked up his iPad and a text appeared. When I asked about it, he denied it, then deflected, backpedalled and then blamed Shelley for being such a nag. I felt my hackles and impatience rising. Instead of managing that, stepping back and being curious, I took on the role of interrogator, willing him to confess and take responsibility.

He did what most of us would do. He shut down, got even more defensive, and accused me of taking his partner’s side.  And in that moment, he was right..

Therapists Have Horsemen Too

We’re good at recognizing the Four Horsemen in our clients. We label them and coach the antidotes. What we talk about less is that as therapists, we can have unique sensitivity to a particular Horseman which can impact the process. 

For me, it’s defensiveness. In working with a client who deflects, obfuscates or blames their partner, I quickly become impatient. In reviewing consultee tapes, I’ve seen therapists come down hard on the angry, critical partner and give the quieter, defensive partner a pass: the loud one looks like the bad guy, the quiet one looks wounded. I also see therapists become cold and sarcastic in confronting contempt in a couple, and stonewalling can make us pursue or withdraw ourselves.

Why It Happens

Researchers Karney and Bradbury call the stable qualities we carry into relationships “enduring vulnerabilities”. A therapist’s Horseman trigger is a kind of enduring vulnerability. It’s a sensitivity. We each have our own histories, nervous systems and families of origin, and some client behaviors push on our sore spots.

Know Your Triggers

Knowing which Horseman triggers you is the key to managing it. Without that awareness, our enduring vulnerabilities can be problematic.

If criticism sets you off, you may side with the partner who is using a gentle start up. Maybe defensiveness pushes your buttons, and you may offer more support to the partner who easily accepts responsibility. If this happens, we exit the therapeutic stance of being the couples’ ally in helping them with their particular Horsemen pattern. We inadvertently take a side and that leaves us with less flexibility to move from one partner to the other with curiosity about their experience.

Criticizing a criticizer will make them feel blamed, and hounding a defensive person for accountability almost guarantees more defensiveness. Partners learn that therapy is a place where someone gets cornered, which is the opposite of what we’re trying to accomplish with dismantling a Horsemen pattern. 

What Is Your Tell?

When working with defensiveness, I know I can quickly get impatient and become like Perry Mason, trying to ferret out the “truth”. I can get terse, and I stop wondering what might be going on. The solve for me is to notice, check in with myself and try to be curious, making a mini-repair that might sound like “let me back up.” This takes me back to being an ally, back to recognizing that defensiveness is often an attempt to avoid shame, and I can label and empathize with that.

Back to Dan……What Repair Looked Like

I told Dan he was right. I said I’d let my frustration with what I saw as defensiveness get in the way of understanding where he was coming from.

His whole posture shifted. He took responsibility for breaking his commitment, mostly. There were a few caveats, but it was a real shift, and Shelley, who had been bracing for another round, de-escalated too.

Why Repair Is Key

The couple sees it modeled. We ask clients to own their part, apologize, and try again. Seeing their therapist take responsibility for a rupture, no matter how minor, and doing that without falling apart, seems to be relieving for couples and is a good learning moment. 

The client who is confronted saves face and feels understood. A defensive person can often lower their guard when someone else goes first.

We have permission to make mistakes and be human.  There’s a freedom to be accepting of our own mistakes and recognizing that we are dealing with the same issues as our clients.

What do you notice about how you feel when any of the Horsemen show up? 

With Anger ? Fear? Anxiety? 

 How do you respond ? 

With Engagement? Being the expert ? Criticizing? Withdrawal?

A note: this applies to the ordinary patterns most couples get stuck in. Where there’s coercion, manipulation, gaslighting or abuse, the dynamic isn’t symmetrical, and this isn’t the frame to use.

Ask Gottman

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sinead Smyth, LMFT is a Certified Gottman Therapist and Level 3 Trainer in Gottman Method Couples Therapy. Her counseling practice, East Bay Relationship Center, has offices in Pleasanton and Alameda, CA, and works with couples, families, teens, and individuals. You can visit her website here.

Recommended products

$30.00

Improve your relationship in 30 days! Backed by over 50 years of research, the 30 Days to a Better Relationship challenge will help you reconnect with your partner and bring more positivity into your relationship. The tools and exercises, delivered once a day for 30 days by email, build on one another and take five minutes or less to complete.

 

Related posts

Couple in therapy session with a therapist.

What Technology Can Not Replace in Therapy

Dana McNeil

Explore what AI cannot replace in couples therapy, from reading emotional cues to clinical judgment, and why human connection remains essential to healing.

Read More

A therapist working with a couple in session.

Everything You Need to Know about Therapy

Kendra Han

Are you wondering when to get therapy? Learn the Gottman signs of relationship distress, and take steps to improve communication, conflict resolution and more.

Read More

A female therapist is working with a client in session.

Decoding the Roles of Therapist, Counselor and Psychiatrist

The Gottman Institute

Confused by the different roles in behavioral health? Learn the distinct differences between a Psychiatrist and a Therapist, and how they work together to save relationships.

Read More

Find a therapist

Finding a Culturally-Relevant Therapist

Jenny Wang

What to ask when you need to know if this therapist is right for you

Read More

Couple on the brink of divorce

We’re on the Brink

Dr. Jenna Scott

When you are disconnected from your partner and unsure if the relationship can survive, there are specific actions to take to dramatically improve the relationship.

Read More

Couple starting sex therapy

Contemplating Starting Sex Therapy? Some Considerations…

Justin Pere

Read More

Improve your Relationship Skills with our Free Newsletters
0